NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY v. DAVID RANDALL ASSOCIATES, INC. et al

  1. March 22, 2022

    Court Lacks Jurisdiction In Insurer TCPA Suit, Car Dealer Says

    Nationwide's bid to avoid covering its policyholder's $22.4 million Telephone Consumer Protection Act judgment should be dismissed from Pennsylvania federal court for lack of jurisdiction, a car dealer with a stake in the case said, arguing the insurer is improperly aggregating claims to satisfy diversity requirements.

  2. March 21, 2022

    Car Dealer Can't Ignore Exclusion In TCPA Suit, Insurer Says

    Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. said it should not be on the hook for a $22.4 million judgment in an underlying lawsuit, arguing that its insured's commercial general liability policy does not provide coverage for liability stemming from Telephone Consumer Protection Act violations. 

  3. February 22, 2022

    Nationwide Can't Use Exclusion In TCPA Suit, Court Told

    A car dealer urged a Pennsylvania federal court to force Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. to indemnify a commercial roofing contractor for a $22.4 million judgment in an underlying Telephone Consumer Protection Act suit, saying the insurer's main argument for avoiding coverage is based on a policy exclusion that isn't valid.

  4. February 15, 2022

    Nationwide Wants Defendant Class In TCPA Coverage Suit

    Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. moved to create a class of defendants in its suit seeking to avoid indemnifying a policyholder for a $22.4 million judgment, asking a Pennsylvania federal court Tuesday to certify the exact same group of plaintiffs that won in the underlying Telephone Consumer Protection Act suit.