General Liability
-
June 02, 2023
State Farm Calif. Exit Could Hurt Market, Last Resort Insurer
State Farm's decision to suspend property insurance sales in California could decrease competition in the homeowners insurance market while straining a last resort coverage option for homeowners and businesses unable to buy traditional insurance, experts say.
-
June 02, 2023
Notice Compliance Ease At Stake In Harvard Admissions Case
A potential First Circuit affirmation of a decision denying Harvard $15 million in coverage due to it not providing proper notice to its insurer could make it onerous for policyholders to comply with notice requirements, attorneys told Law360 ahead of oral arguments in the case.
-
June 02, 2023
Insurance Group Urges 1st Circ. To Back Recoupment Ruling
An insurance trade group asked the First Circuit to affirm a Massachusetts federal court's ruling that Berkley National Insurance is entitled to recoup costs it incurred in defending and settling a man's foot infection claims, saying an insurer cannot be expected to defend and indemnify a policyholder for noncovered claims.
-
June 02, 2023
Calif. Panel Upholds Auto Dealer's $7.5M Coverage Award
An auto dealership is entitled to more than $7.5 million from its insurer for a leased building that was destroyed in a fire, a California appeals panel said, finding a lower court correctly ruled the policyholder had an insurable interest in the property.
-
June 01, 2023
Insurer Denied Win In Liquor Store Shooting Coverage Dispute
An Illinois federal judge rejected State Automobile Mutual Insurance Co.'s bid for an early win in its row with a gas station and liquor store facing an underlying lawsuit over a shooting, finding Thursday that the store's owner notified the insurer of the claim in a reasonable time.
-
June 01, 2023
State Farm Can't Pause Lyft Assault Coverage Suit
A State Farm unit cannot challenge a stay of its dispute over coverage for a pair of policyholders accused of assaulting a Lyft driver, an Illinois state appeals court ruled, saying the insurer was the one to "induce" the court to order a pause in the case.
-
June 01, 2023
Co. Seeks Over $1M For Unpaid Work At US Army Facility
Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co. and the prime construction contractor for a U.S. Army facility failed to pay more than $1 million owed to a subcontractor after it performed all required work, the subcontractor told a Massachusetts federal court, accusing the prime contractor of breach of contract.
-
June 01, 2023
11th Circ. Says Primary Insurer On Hook For $3M Settlement
The Eleventh Circuit affirmed that a Georgia apartment complex property owner's primary insurer must contribute to a $3 million settlement for a fatal shooting before excess coverage can kick in, finding that state law requires primary policies to precede umbrella policies even when the former contains an "excess clause."
-
June 01, 2023
Chocolatier Asks 2nd Circ. For New Trial On Sandy Coverage
A candymaker told the Second Circuit on Wednesday that it should get a new trial on whether its insurer wrongfully denied full coverage for $53 million in damages caused by Superstorm Sandy, arguing evidence presented by the carrier did not clarify policy ambiguities.
-
June 01, 2023
Walmart Toxic Baby Food Claims Not Covered, Insurer Says
A Nationwide unit should have no duty to defend Walmart as an additional insured in multiple suits accusing the retail giant of selling baby food products with dangerous levels of heavy metals, the insurer told an Illinois federal court.
-
June 01, 2023
Insurer Says Wingstop Isn't Covered For Biometric Data Suit
A Wingstop restaurant isn't covered for a proposed class action claiming it violated the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act by making employees use a biometric time clock to track hours, the franchise's insurer told an Illinois federal court.
-
June 01, 2023
Judge Adds $8M To Wash. Gas Plant's $11M Coverage Win
A Washington federal court awarded a natural gas plant an additional $7.8 million in prejudgment interest, refusing to depart from a jury's finding that awarded the plant $11 million in a dispute with a Chubb unit over coverage for losses resulting from the facility's shutdown.
-
May 31, 2023
Canceling Auto Policy Doesn't Alter Past, Mich. Justices Say
A driver whose auto insurance policy was yanked for fraud can still pursue damages from the driver who rear-ended her, despite Michigan's bar on suits from uninsured drivers, the Michigan Supreme Court held Wednesday, ruling rescission does not "alter reality or act as a DeLorean time machine."
-
May 31, 2023
Mont. Justices Uphold Insurer's Win In Landscaping Dispute
The Montana Supreme Court unanimously affirmed a ruling relieving an insurer of covering a general contractor after a couple alleged he failed to uphold their buy-sell agreement following a landscaper's accusations that he wasn't paid for his work, finding the allegations didn't trigger coverage under a liability policy.
-
May 31, 2023
3rd Circ. Frees Insurer From Covering $13M Fracking Claim
A fracking company's insurer is off the hook for damages its client caused to another party's gas wells after the Third Circuit ruled Wednesday that claims for poor workmanship are not "occurrences" that would trigger coverage under Pennsylvania law.
-
May 31, 2023
NC Manufacturer To Disband Amid Mountain Of Benzene Suits
A former manufacturing giant with deep roots in North Carolina is looking to dissolve amid an onslaught of litigation over purported exposure to the cancer-causing chemical compound benzene, saying insurance won't cover the suits and its liabilities now far exceed its assets.
-
May 31, 2023
HVAC Co. Owes $2.9M For Defective Heater Fire, Insurer Says
Travelers Property Casualty Co. of America told a New York federal court Wednesday that manufacturer Friedrich Air Conditioning LLC and one of its parts suppliers owe the insurer more than $2.9 million for fire damage caused by a defective heating unit.
-
May 31, 2023
No Coverage For Exxon Mobil Site Fatality, 5th Circ. Told
The insurer for an Exxon Mobil subcontractor urged the Fifth Circuit to affirm that it doesn't have to defend or indemnify the general contractor's insurer in a lawsuit over a worker's on-the-job death, saying a lower court correctly found the decedent wasn't a covered employee under the subcontractor's policy.
-
May 31, 2023
School Board Says Insurer Must Cover $50M Sex Abuse Suits
An insurer must defend a school board facing separate $50 million lawsuits alleging a teacher routinely sexually abused two students in the 1960s and 1970s, the board told a New Jersey federal court, arguing the insurer wrongfully refused to defend the lawsuits in full.
-
May 31, 2023
Strip Club Loses Attempt To Sink BIPA Coverage Suit
A strip club's attempt to escape a suit from its insurer over coverage of biometric privacy claims was denied by an Illinois federal judge, who ruled the insurer did not need to add the club's co-owner as a defendant because the co-owner and the club had the same interest in the suit.
-
May 30, 2023
Geico Asks Full 5th Circ. To Reconsider Class Cert. Ruling
Geico urged the Fifth Circuit to grant an en banc rehearing of the court's decision to affirm the certification of a class of policyholders claiming the insurer underpaid the actual cash value of their totaled vehicles, arguing the appellate court contradicted U.S. Supreme Court and circuit precedent.
-
May 30, 2023
Oil Co. Asks 5th Circ. To Revive Faulty Cement Coverage Row
An oil and gas producer urged the Fifth Circuit to revive its lawsuit seeking to hold Lloyd's of London underwriters liable for a settlement it reached with a now-bankrupt oil field services firm over faulty cement, asserting that it proved the underwriters flouted their duty to defend and indemnify.
-
May 30, 2023
Panelists Urge Carriers To Avoid 'Reverse Bad Faith' Claims
Insurers locked in a coverage fight with a policyholder should refrain from asserting a "reverse bad faith" claim, a panel of attorneys said in a webinar Tuesday, explaining that a vast majority of courts do not recognize it as a viable cause of action.
-
May 30, 2023
Insurers Seek Relief From Defense Of Asbestos Suits
A drywall and paint company is exploiting its primary insurers by allowing them to pay to defend numerous lawsuits against it in connection with asbestos injuries while using an excess insurer to pay settlements to never exhaust its primary limits, the primary insurers told a Texas federal court.
-
May 30, 2023
NJ Panel Says Insurer Needn't Cover Tainted Concrete Claim
A trucking company's insurer is not obligated to pay a nearly $1 million judgment awarded against its policyholder to a concrete company that received a contaminated batch of concrete materials, a New Jersey state appeals court ruled Tuesday, finding that the policy's handling of property and completed operations exclusions apply.

Port Of Portland Says Insurers Flouting Superfund Coverage
A slew of insurers must cover the Port of Portland for costs incurred remediating a portion of the Willamette River after the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency ordered it to do so, the port told an Oregon federal court, citing policies that date back to the '20s and '30s.

6th Circ. Affirms Insurer Win In False Ad Suit Coverage Spat
A Sixth Circuit panel on Thursday dealt a win to insurance companies claiming they shouldn't have to defend a Michigan coffee company accused of falsely advertising that its coffee came from the Kona region in Hawaii, saying the underlying complaint didn't allege claims that triggered coverage.

Wholesaler, Chubb Vying For Win In Opioid Coverage Fight
A drug wholesaler and a Chubb unit each went for a quick win in a dispute over the defense against 115 opioid-related suits, telling a North Carolina federal judge in competing motions filed Tuesday why a directors and officers policy could or could not trigger the carrier's obligations.
Expert Analysis
-
How Mich. Bill Could Reshape State's Insurance Landscape
A recently introduced Michigan Senate bill would bar insurers from delaying, denying or failing to pay a claim unless there is a reasonable basis found in the policy, but its requirement calling for written standards for claims adjusting could create liability issues for large insurers, says Emily Coyle at Plunkett Cooney.
-
PFAS Coverage Litigation Strategy Lessons For Policyholders
While policyholders' efforts to recover insurance proceeds for PFAS-related costs are in the early stages, it appears from litigation so far that substantial coverage should be available for PFAS-related liabilities, including both defense costs and indemnity payments in connection with those liabilities, say Benedict Lenhart and Alexis Dyschkant at Covington.
-
Exxon Ruling Highlights Additional Insured Coverage Conflict
Despite the Texas Supreme Court's recent decision in Exxon Mobil v. National Union, finding that contractual minimum insurance requirements cannot be used as a ceiling to bar umbrella coverage, the case nevertheless illustrates insurers' aggressive tactics to reduce the scope of additional insured coverage, say David Kroeger and Steven Tinetti at Jenner & Block.
-
Tackling Long-Tail Legacy Liability Risk: A Defendant's Toolkit
Johnson & Johnson was recently rebuffed in its efforts to employ the "Texas Two-Step," which is likely to affect this increasingly popular method to isolate and spin off large asbestos and talc liabilities, but companies have multiple options to reduce long-tail legacy liability risk, says Stephen Hoke at Hoke LLC.
-
Climate Reporting Regs Mean New Risks To Insure
As regulators in the U.S., U.K. and beyond implement new climate-related investment and disclosure requirements for corporations, decision makers should investigate whether their insurance policies offer the right coverage to respond to the legal and regulatory risks of this increased scrutiny, says David Cummings at Reed Smith.
-
Md. Abuse Law Makes Past Liability Coverage Review Vital
Maryland is the first state to allow an indefinite lookback period for previously time-barred lawsuits by victims of child sexual abuse against public and private entities — and lawsuits brought under the new law likely will implicate coverage under insurance policies issued over the past 80 years or longer, say Michael Levine and Olivia Bushman at Hunton.
-
Unpacking NY's Revamped Wrongful Death Bill
Legislation to amend New York’s wrongful death law, introduced May 2, proposes more limited reforms than an earlier version the governor vetoed in January, but will likely still face strong opposition due to the severe financial impacts it would have on insurers’ set premiums and reserves, say Eric Andrew and David Adams at Hurwitz Fine.
-
NY Ruling Highlights Need For Specific Insurance Disclaimers
New York coverage counsel responsible for writing disclaimer letters should heed a recent appellate decision, Bahnuk v. Countryway Insurance, in which the letter sent to the plaintiff was deemed to be insufficiently specific, leaving the insurance company on the hook for coverage, says Dan Kohane at Hurwitz Fine.
-
Big Oil Certiorari Denial May Alter Climate Change Litigation
The U.S. Supreme Court's Monday decision not to review a handful of forum disputes in oil industry climate change litigation means that similar cases may face less corporate-friendly state courts, and insurers may see greater defense and damages exposures from Big Oil clients, say Dennis Anderson and Deepa Sutherland at Zelle.
-
5 Tips For Filing Gov't Notices After Insurance Producer M&A
As insurance producer acquisition activity picks up in 2023, requiring a daunting process of notifying information changes to each Department of Insurance where the entity is licensed, certain best practices will help buyers alleviate frustration and avoid administrative actions and fines, say attorneys at Foley & Lardner.
-
Policyholder Lessons From Sandy No-Coverage Decision
A New York federal court recently decided that in the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy, Madelaine Chocolate knew Great Northern Insurance’s all-risk policy offered no coverage for storm surge — an important reminder that policyholders should review policy language for ambiguities or anti-concurrent causation clauses, say Dennis Artese and Joshua Zelen at Anderson Kill.
-
Insureds' Notice Pleading May Be Insufficient In Federal Court
A recent New Jersey federal court ruling in Bauman v. Hanover Insurance held that bare-bones notice pleading was insufficient and dismissed the policyholder's coverage complaint, a reminder that courts may require more than an expression of general disagreement with an insurance company's denial letter to proceed with the case, says Eugene Killian at The Killian Firm.
-
5th Circ. Offers Expert Opinion Guidance For Insurance Cases
A recent Fifth Circuit decision in Majestic Oil v. Lloyd's of London provides insight into how Texas' concurrent causation doctrine could affect insurance cases where the cause of damage is at issue, and raises considerations for litigants faced with new or revised expert reports after the deadline has passed, say Brian Scarbrough and Cianan Lesley at Jenner & Block.