Property

  • December 12, 2023

    Sprinkler Co. Inks Deal To End $1.1M Water Damage Suit

    An insurer settled its Washington federal court case against a Michigan-based fire prevention company after blaming the company's sprinkler for causing over $1.1 million in water damage to a Seattle apartment building when it drenched the place without cause.

  • December 11, 2023

    8th Circ. Nixes Minn. Concert Venue's COVID-19 Coverage Bid

    An Eighth Circuit panel affirmed the dismissal of a Minneapolis entertainment venue's lawsuit for pandemic-related losses, upholding on Monday a lower court's ruling in favor of the venue's insurer.

  • December 11, 2023

    Dry Cleaner Says Excess Policies Cover Chemical Cleanup

    A dry cleaning company urged a New Mexico federal court to find that several excess insurers owe coverage for the cleanup costs of a property contamination where the company operated, arguing that the damages exceed primary limits of coverage.

  • December 11, 2023

    Insurer Can't Arbitrate Storm Coverage Row, 2nd Circ. Affirms

    A Travelers unit cannot force an independent school district in Texas to arbitrate its storm damage claim in Connecticut, the Second Circuit held Monday, affirming that the district is not bound by an arbitration clause in a reinsurance contract it was not party to.

  • December 11, 2023

    5th Circ. Denies Allstate Rehearing Bid In Roof Coverage Spat

    The Fifth Circuit rejected an Allstate unit's request for a rehearing Monday in a coverage dispute over a policyholder's roof damage, after a three-judge appeals panel found that a Texas federal court failed to take into proper account the policyholder's expert's testimony.

  • December 11, 2023

    Zurich, Hospital Differ On 1st Circ. Flood Coverage Questions

    The owner and operator of a Massachusetts hospital filed a dueling response with Zurich American Insurance Co. to the First Circuit's request for the proposed language of a question it may certify to the state's high court concerning their flood coverage dispute.

  • December 11, 2023

    No Virus Coverage For Casino Operator, Minn. Panel Rules

    A Minnesota state appeals court upheld the dismissal of a casino and golf course operator's bid for COVID-19 business-interruption coverage Monday, finding the operator failed to claim that COVID-19 was actually present at its property.

  • December 11, 2023

    Plastics Co., Insurers Fail In $4M Asbestos Claim Mediation

    A plastics manufacturer and its two insurers informed a Pennsylvania federal court Monday that they failed to reach an agreement during mediation of a $4 million dispute over coverage for the settlement of an underlying asbestos claim.

  • December 08, 2023

    Pa. Justices Reject Consolidation Of Future COVID Cases

    The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania on Friday held that an Allegheny County judge — one of few to rule in favor of businesses seeking insurance coverage for losses stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic — cannot consolidate all future pandemic cases against Erie Insurance Exchange in her courtroom, ruling that she exceeded her authority in doing so.

  • December 08, 2023

    Wrong Remedy Sought By Carrier In Sandy Suit, Insurer Says

    A subcontractor's insurer fought carrier Affiliated FM's efforts Friday to escape the insurer's lawsuit seeking to avoid covering a contractor in an underlying suit Affiliated brought to recover $4.5 million it paid a landlord for Superstorm Sandy damages, saying the carrier is pursuing an improper legal remedy.

  • December 08, 2023

    Carriers Urge Pa. Justices To Flip Policyholder Pandemic Win

    The insurers of a Pittsburgh dental practice told the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in an appeal Friday to recognize that, like many other plaintiffs, the dentist can't be covered for his COVID-19 losses because there was no physical damage to his office.

  • December 08, 2023

    Fla. Property Owner Sues Insurer For $1.2M In Ian Coverage

    A Florida property owner took a QBE subsidiary to federal court over more than $1.2 million in unpaid coverage for damage caused by Hurricane Ian, alleging the insurer wrongfully refused to pay for its losses.

  • December 08, 2023

    Coverage Fight Over $14M Hardware Theft Dropped After Deal

    A California federal court tossed a dispute between IT distribution company Synnex Corp. and Axis Insurance Co. over coverage for a nearly $14 million theft of computer hardware from Synnex's warehouse in Mexico City, after the parties told the court in October they reached a settlement.

  • December 08, 2023

    Insurer Can't Keep Info Secret In Ga. Church Fire Damage Suit

    A Georgia federal judge shot down an insurance company's bid Friday to keep certain information confidential in a dispute over fire damage suffered by a Conyers, Georgia, church in 2022.

  • December 08, 2023

    Costco, Liberty Mutual Settle Slip-And-Fall Coverage Row

    Costco and a Liberty Mutual unit have agreed to settle their dispute over coverage for an underlying slip-and-fall suit, resolving the retail giant's bid to have the insurer reimburse its defense and settlement costs.

  • December 07, 2023

    Carrier Says Reinsurer Failed To Reimburse Claims It Paid Out

    An Iowa-based insurer took a Chinese reinsurance company to federal court after it "serially breached" its obligations to reimburse property insurance coverage claims paid to insured companies in energy, mining and other industries.

  • December 07, 2023

    Fla. Fairfield Inn Must Arbitrate Hurricane Damage Fight

    A Florida federal judge ordered the owner of a Fairfield Inn in Tampa to arbitrate its hurricane damage dispute in New York with its insurers, saying the property owner's argument that arbitration unfairly favored insurers was irrelevant since the dispute involved a foreign underwriter.

  • December 07, 2023

    Fla. Rulings Splinter Suit Notice Requirement Across State

    Conflicting state appellate rulings in Florida may create uncertainty for property insurance policyholders and federal courts about whether a state law requiring such policyholders to notify regulators before suing their insurers applies to policies that predate the law's passage, experts say.

  • December 07, 2023

    Hurricane Victim Urges Keeping Suit Over Solicitations Alive

    A woman suing Houston law firm McClenny Moseley & Associates PLLC over its alleged illegal solicitation of clients after a hurricane urged the Southern District of Texas Wednesday to reject the recommendation of a federal magistrate judge and keep her proposed class action alive.

  • December 07, 2023

    Insurer Asks Court To Name Appraiser In Wind Damage Fight

    Owners Insurance Co. asked an Alabama federal court to appoint a neutral umpire to oversee an appraisal in its more than $500,000 tornado coverage dispute with a museum association concerning wind damage to a historic Selma mansion.

  • December 06, 2023

    O'Connor's Measured Approach Visible In Insurance Cases

    The late Justice Sandra Day O'Connor's evenhanded judicial approach hardly wavered when considering insurance cases despite their relative rarity before the high court, with her thoughtfulness shining through on issues ranging from insurance for deposits to gender-based pension plans and states' taxation of insurers.

  • December 06, 2023

    Nationwide, Property Owner Settle $1M Hailstorm Dispute

    Nationwide and a San Antonio property owner reached an agreement in a $1 million coverage dispute over hailstorm damage, according to a notice filed Wednesday in Texas federal court.

  • December 06, 2023

    Tory Burch Stores Not Damaged By COVID, NJ Panel Says

    A New Jersey appeals court dealt another blow Wednesday to Tory Burch LLC's pandemic coverage bid, agreeing with a lower court's ruling that the fashion retailer cannot argue that loss of revenue due to pandemic shutdowns counts as property damage or loss.

  • December 06, 2023

    Liberty Mutual Says Co.'s Fees In Shipping Row Not Covered

    Liberty Mutual pushed back on a Houston-based cement company's bid for an early win in their dispute over coverage for more than $738,000 in penalties resulting from a shipping mishap, arguing in Louisiana federal court that the plain language of its policy does not cover the company's fees.

  • December 06, 2023

    Real Estate Co. Says Insurer Won't Pay For $700K Damage

    A Nebraska real estate investment company told a federal court that its insurer wrongly balked at its claims for over $700,000 in hailstorm losses despite numerous appraisals showing damage to its HVAC systems.

Expert Analysis

  • COVID Rulings May Support Ransomware Insurance Denials

    Author Photo

    A recent spate of pandemic-related insurance decisions — where federal courts found that a temporary inability to use property doesn't qualify as physical loss or damage for coverage purposes — may be used as favorable precedent by cyber insurers denying ransomware loss claims for temporary inability to access data, say Thomas Caswell and Peter Kelly Golfman at Zelle.

  • 3 Risk Management Lessons From Pandemic Insurance Wars

    Author Photo

    As appellate decisions in COVID-19 business interruption insurance claims continue to clarify the state of the law, there are some things that policyholders' lawyers and risk managers can do in the meantime to help prepare for future unforeseen events affecting coverage, says Peter Halprin at Pasich.

  • Why Legacy Insurance May Not Protect Adopters Of Bitcoin

    Author Photo

    Evidenced by El Salvador's adoption of the Bitcoin standard this week, there is an emerging need for insurance products to cover the risk of owning and holding the digital asset, as it may not fall into the protected categories in legacy insurance products, say attorneys at Mound Cotton.

  • Ill. BIPA Ruling Marks Critical Win For Silent Cyber Coverage

    Author Photo

    The Illinois Supreme Court's recent decision in West Bend Mutual v. Krishna Schaumburg Tan, confirming that commercial general liability policies do not have to include specific language to cover claims under the Biometric Information Privacy Act, represents a critical victory for policyholders, but leaves unresolved issues in the battle over BIPA coverage, says Tae Andrews at Miller Friel.

  • NY Badly Needs Bad Faith Bill To Hold Insurers Accountable

    Author Photo

    Contrary to a recent Law360 guest article that contends New York state's insurance reform bill would unfairly tip the scales against insurers, Edward Steinberg at the New York State Trial Lawyers Association argues the law is necessary to hold insurers accountable for acting in bad faith, and would protect policyholders and injured parties alike.

  • Insurers Have Cause For Optimism In Labor Cost Rulings

    Author Photo

    Recent decisions from the high courts of South Carolina and North Carolina — holding that embedded labor costs can be depreciated from the replacement cost of property — bolster insurers’ moderate edge in these disputes and point to important implications for both insureds and insurers, says Richard Mason at MasonADR.

  • Predictions On Pandemic's Lasting Impact On Legal Education

    Author Photo

    The pandemic accelerated the pace of technological change for legal education, and some of the changes to how law school courses are taught and on-campus interviews are conducted may be here to stay, says Leonard Baynes at the University of Houston.

  • Firms Should Use Surveys To Make Smart Legal Tech Choices

    Author Photo

    The utility of legal technology innovations may be limited without clear data and objectives from the outset, but targeted surveys can provide specific insights that enable law firms to adopt the most appropriate and efficient tech solutions, says Tim Scott at Frogslayer.

  • Don't Forget Due Diligence In Race For Lateral Associate Hires

    Author Photo

    Amid high demand for associates and aggressive competition to attract talent, law firms should take three key steps to conduct meaningful prehire due diligence and safeguard against lateral hiring mistakes that can hurt their revenue and reputation, says Michael Ellenhorn at Decipher.

  • Insurance Could Be A Solution To Microchip Shortage Losses

    Author Photo

    To the extent that companies experiencing lost income from the global microchip shortage have contingent business interruption or dependent property coverage and can trace their impaired revenues to physical loss or damage to a supplier, there may be some potential for insurance recovery, says Micah Skidmore at Haynes and Boone.

  • 5 Steps For Law Firms Rethinking Flexible Work Post-COVID

    Author Photo

    A flexible work environment will be key to recruiting and retention efforts post-pandemic, so law firms must develop comprehensive policies that solidify expectations and boundaries on accommodations such as flextime, remote work and reduced hours, says Manar Morales at the Diversity & Flexibility Alliance.

  • NY Bad Faith Bill Would Tip The Scales Against Insurers

    Author Photo

    A recently introduced New York bill proposes a statutory cause of action for insurance company bad faith when legal remedies already exist, which may dangerously upset the balance between insurers and policyholders, say attorneys at Hurwitz & Fine.

  • Judge's Rebuke Of Mass. AG Has Lessons For All Attorneys

    Author Photo

    A Massachusetts federal judge’s recent rebuke of the state Attorney General’s Office for refusing to respond to discovery requests in Alliance for Automotive Innovation v. Healey highlights six important considerations for attorneys who want to avoid the dreaded benchslap, say Alison Eggers and Dallin Wilson at Seyfarth.  

Can't find the article you're looking for? Click here to search the Insurance Authority Property archive.