Law360, New York (August 24, 2012, 8:22 PM ET) -- A Pennsylvania federal judge ruled Thursday that the receivership estate of convicted Ponzi schemer Robert Stinson Jr. can proceed with a lawsuit alleging the Morningstar Inc. investment ratings agency contributed to Stinson's fraud by giving one of his hedge funds its top rating.
Chicago-based Morningstar argued in a motion to dismiss the case in June that the First Amendment shielded it from third-party liability for legitimizing Stinson's Life’s Good STABL Mortgage Fund and attracting investors who otherwise would not have given him money.