Try our Advanced Search for more refined results
Legal Industry - June, 2020
365 articles
- Kasowitz Faces 3rd Suit Alleging Partner Was Wrongly Fired
- 2nd Circ. Frees Attorneys Accused Of Molotov Attack
- DC Bar OKs Cryptocurrency Payments For Legal Fees
- Newsom Slashes $200M From Calif. Courts In New Budget
- Legal Diversity Pros Urge Concrete Change From Leaders
- Procopio Boosts IP Practice In Calif. With 7 Arent Fox Attys
- Key Senators Want To Add New Federal Judgeships This Year
- NY Courthouses To Check Body Temps: 100° Or Less To Enter
- Top US Trade Official Who Led China Talks To Rejoin Skadden
- Colo. Justices Say Courts Can Extend Speedy Trial Period
- Coronavirus Regulations: A State-By-State Week In Review
- What You Say In Online Mediation May Be Discoverable
- Texas Should Cancel Its 2020 Bar Exam
- MSG Entertainment Hires First GC After April Spinoff
- NY Law Firm Hits Hartford With COVID-19 Coverage Suit
- Bainbridge Of Pierce Bainbridge Sets Up Own Firm In Calif.
- Ex-King & Spalding Atty Says Benefits Cutoff Violated Law
- Sedgwick Trustee Files Suit Over Unpaid Legal Fees
- Calif. District Chief Cedes Role After 'Street-Smart' Remark
- Atty Says Founders Left Online Legal Marketplace In Ruins
- Katten To Lay Off Some Workers Furloughed Amid Pandemic
- Texas Prosecutor Resigns After Facebook Post About Nazis
- St. Louis Injury Attys Point Guns At Protesters Outside Home
- Fed. Circ. Allows Courthouse Access On Case-By-Case Basis
- Boies Schiller Exits Continue With Litigator's Jump To Mintz
- Outcry Over Fla.'s In-Person Bar Exam Intensifies
- Litigious Porn Studio Ends Battle With Former Law Firm
- The Top In-House Hires Of June
- Kozinski Moves To Nix Atty's Suit Over Porn Complaints
- May It Please The Camera: Zoom Trials Demand New Skills
- 2nd Atty Denies Molotov Charges As Supporters Flood Call
- 15 Minutes With Toyota Material Handling's General Counsel
- Justices Won't Hear Ex-Greenberg Atty's Fight With OCC
- 10 Tips For A Successful Remote Arbitration Hearing
- Texas Courts Re-Closing Amid COVID-19 Spike
- Court Accused Of Blocking Public Access To Trials Amid Virus
- Will Spotlight On Racial Justice Force More Diverse Juries?
- In Case You Missed It: Hottest Firms And Stories On Law360
- Outside Pa.'s Big Cities, A Look At Trial Work In The Pandemic
- Law Leaders On Managing Through A Crisis — Again
- Berkeley Law Follows Harvard With Fully Online Fall Semester
- Legal Tech Download: Hogan Lovells, Eversheds, UnitedLex
- Law360's Pro Say: BigLaw V. BigLandlord
- NYT Staffers' Court Access Suspended Over Zoom Screenshot
- Ill. Court Revives Chicago Firm's $9.8M Divorce Case Fee Bid
- To Achieve Diversity, Law Firms Must Reinvent Hiring Process
- Legal Assistant Cops To Fraud Using Firm's Postage Meter
- GC Cheat Sheet: The Hottest Corporate News Of The Week
- Minnesota Might Allow Law Grads To Bypass Bar Exam
- Firms Tread Carefully Amid California's Staggered Reopening
- State Court Corporate Cases Dip Amid COVID-19
- Lawmakers Urge Courts To Keep Streaming After COVID-19
- PTAB Judges Dish On Argument Strategy In New Atty Training
- Law360's Weekly Verdict: Legal Lions & Lambs
- Supreme Court On Pace For First July Opinions In 24 Years
- The Term: Where Are All The Opinions?
- Cybersecurity Steps For Law Firms Amid Heightened Risks
- Sens. Advance Bill To Have Watchdog Probe DOJ Attys
- 200 In-House Attys Urge Congress To Up Legal Aid Funding
- SEC Chief Asked Trump For Berman's Job Days Before Ouster
- Law Firms Team With ACLU To Fight Racism In La. Policing
- Ex-BigLaw Atty's In-Person Depo Bid Tossed As 'Tomfoolery'
- Flynn Case Raises Questions Of Appellate Courts' Power
- Burford Takes Equity In UK Dispute Resolution Firm
- Winston & Strawn Forms China Alliance, As McDermott Exits
- Morgan Lewis Nabs 9-Member London IP Team From Cooley
- Diversity Dominates Quick Hearing For 6 Judicial Picks
- BigLaw Among Scores Of Firms In New Anti-Racism Alliance
- BigLaw Attorney Hoping To End WTO's 'Unprecedented Crisis'
- 3 Ways Law Firms Can Be More LGBT Inclusive Right Now
- Baker McKenzie Delays First-Year Associate Program
- It's Time For Law Firms To Support Work-From-Home Culture
- Ex-Fox Rothschild Atty Calls Sex Assault Suit 'Implausible'
- Pryor Cashman Atty Pleads Not Guilty To Torching Cop Car
- McDermott Atty Faults Vets Home's 'Baffling' Virus Response
- Law Firm Leaders: Hueston Hennigan's John Hueston
- Republicans Keep Confirming Unqualified Judicial Nominees
- Trump's Circuit Judges Take Aim At Regulators
- How Environmental Law Is Shifting Under Trump's Judges
- Trump's Judicial Picks To Sway Immigration Law For Years
- How Trump's Judges Are Handling Abortion Rights And ACA
- How Trump's Judicial Picks Have Changed Employment Law
- How Trump Forever Changed Judicial Nominations
- Charting Trump's Judicial Impact Across 200 Confirmations
- The Ones That Got Away: Trump's 12 Failed Judicial Nominees
- 5th Circ. Pick Clears Senate In 200th Confirmation For Trump
- DC Circ. Nixes Charges Against Ex-Trump Adviser Flynn
- Bayer Foe Blocked From Serving Docs Via Email Amid Virus
- Jenner & Block Says Landlord, Not Firm, Owes In Rent Fight
- Courts In NYC To Begin Phase 2 Of Reopening Plan
- Stone Prosecutor Says DOJ Politicized Case Amid Trump Ties
- Legal Industry's Metrics In 2020 'Not Bad' Despite Pandemic
- Droves Of In-House Counsel Might Jump Ship Over Pay Issues
- Clients' Speed Paying Bills Could Make Or Break Law Firms
- ABA Debate On Money Laundering Rule Lives On After Alert
- Dechert's Philly Office Gets OK To Claim Double-Dip Tax Break
- Ex-Davis Polk Atty's Counsel Allowed To Exit Race Bias Suit
- Tips For Crafting The Perfect Law Firm Alert
- Coronavirus Regulations: A State-By-State Week In Review
- 2nd Circ. Mulls Bail In Attorneys' 'Unimaginable' Molotov Case
- Holland & Hart Latest To Cut Pay As Virus Persists
- Susman Godfrey Founder Diagnosed With COVID-19
- NY Judge Who Called Atty The C-Word Booted From Bench
- Atty Who Quit DOJ Over Stone's Case Joins Munger Tolles
- NY Bar: Attys Not Bound To Rep Ex-Clients After Leaving Firm
- Telework Still Reigns As NYC Firms Cleared To Reopen Offices
- SEC Chair's Nomination To Lead SDNY Raises Eyebrows
- Kozinski Wins Revival Of 'Shape Of Water' IP Suit At 9th Circ.
- Lawyer Wants Out Of Ex-Davis Polk Atty's Race Bias Suit
- Judging A Book: Elrod Reviews 'Shortlisted'
- Mandatory State Bars Likely To Remain Intact, For Now
- Ex-Seyfarth Partner's Sons Say Estate Attys Exploited Dad
- NH Won't Probe Bar Applicants On Mental Health
- 15 Minutes With Stretto's General Counsel
- Perkins Coie Settles Secretary's Age Bias Suit
- Midcareer Female Attys Of Color Say Barriers Remain High
- Shock, Disappointment In SDNY Circles Over Berman Ouster
- The Law Behind The Strange Departure Of US Atty Berman
- After Standoff With Barr, Manhattan US Atty Steps Down
- In Case You Missed It: Hottest Firms And Stories On Law360
- Roundup Atty, Partner Cop To $200M Corporate Extortion Plot
- Valero's Top Atty Joins C-Suite As Deputy Rises To GC
- Law360 Pro Say: High Court Surprises On DACA, LGBT Rights
- New York City Law Firms OK'd To Reopen Offices Monday
- How BigLaw Can Go Beyond Lip Service On Racial Justice
- NJ High Court Pick Would Restore Diversity On State Bench
- 11 Keys To Success At Remote Mediation
- Boies Loses 4 More Litigators To King & Spalding
- Chicago Firm Says COVID-19 Dangers Should Reduce Rent
- Video Shows Molotov Attys Endangered 7, Feds Tell 2nd Circ.
- Atty Indicted For Transporting Pot On Private Jet, Feds Say
- GC Cheat Sheet: The Hottest Corporate News Of The Week
- NY Drops 'Outdated' Restriction On Law Firm Names
- Explosion Of BigLaw Firms Observing Juneteenth Continues
- Law Grad Who Hid Positive Pot Test Can't Take Bar Exam
- Trump Taps SEC Senior Counsel For Dem Commissioner Seat
- The Term: DACA, Title VII Bombshells Land Early
- Trump Makes Justices An Election Issue After Bad Week
- How Attys Hope To Prevent Recession-Era Diversity Mistakes
- Law360's Weekly Verdict: Legal Lions & Lambs
- Courts In NY, Philadelphia, Del. To Close For Juneteenth
- Philly Firm Sues Santander Over Botched PPP Loan Rollout
- Judge Will Fight Lieff Cabraser In 1st Circ. Atty Fee Appeal
- Pandemic Could Bring Student Exodus From Legal Profession
- Firms Recorded 2nd-Best Year Of Pro Bono Work In 2019
- Fired King & Spalding Atty Insists On In-Person Depositions
- Divided Senate Confirms McConnell Protege To DC Circ.
- Backers Of Anti-Bias Rule For Attys Reject 'PC Police' Tag
- Republican Sens. Press Judicial Picks On LGBTQ Ruling
- Flynn Blasts 'Partisan Assault' By Court-Appointed Counsel
- Spike In Work Overshadowed By Billing Woes For Law Firms
- Teleconference Not Ideal For Mediating IP Fight, AI Co. Says
- For Black Attorneys, Floyd Killing Hits Home
- Law Firm Leaders: Fish & Richardson's John Adkisson
- Former FTC Official Joins Think Tank As Deputy GC
- Judge Refuses To Exit Trans Athlete Suit Over Word Choice
- Ex-Okla. GC Who Faked Email Threats Gets Suspension
- The Privilege Implications Of Using Online Collaboration Tools
- Ex-Felons In DC Can Serve As Jurors After 1-Year Wait
- More Firms Opt To Observe Juneteenth As A Holiday
- DLA Piper Accused Of Double-Crossing Propane Client
- Federal Indictments Return To NYC As Grand Juries Gather
- Davis Polk Says Ex-Associate 'Rewriting' Race Bias Suit
- Noel Francisco Stepping Down As Solicitor General
- Airman Linked To 'Boogaloo' Charged In Oakland Court Killing
- How Gorsuch's Textualism Won A Major LGBTQ Rights Victory
- DOJ Whistleblowers To Testify On Political Interference
- Hiring From The Top: Firms Target Rainmakers Amid Virus
- Cellino & Barnes Battle Ends With Deal To Wind Down Firm
- BigLaw Embraces Juneteenth As A Holiday
- Sheppard Mullin, Georgetown Law Team Up On Police Training
- Clifford Chance Reduces Bonus Pool Due To COVID-19
- JAMS Wants Justices To Take Up Monster Arbitrator Bias Case
- Twitter Taps Atty From FBI's Russia Probe As Deputy GC
- Confronting Mental Distress In The Legal Profession
- Central NY Courts To Resume In-Person Proceedings
- Coronavirus Regulations: A State-By-State Week In Review
- Calif. Judges Get OK To Defend Rulings During Elections
- Counsel Who Care: How Attys Are Helping During A Crisis
- MoFo Finds COVID-19 Optimism Growing Among Legal Pros
- More BigLaw Firms To Observe Juneteenth As Holiday
- Landmark LGBT Ruling May Create Change In Law Firms
- Fed. Circ. Backs PACER In Atty's Suit Over Opinion Fees
- Trump Taps 2 For Federal Bench In Miss., Claims Court
- Litigation Finance Investments Are Not Risk-Free Loans
- Trial Recess: Allison Brown On Changing Firms Amid Chaos
- LegalZoom Taps The Honest Co.'s GC As Top Lawyer
- 4 Ways Coronavirus May Forever Change Legal Tech
- 15 Minutes With Discovery's General Counsel
- The Law360 400: Tracking The Largest US Law Firms
- As Wash. Ends Access Program, Advocates Fear Ripple Effect
- Will Headcount Matter After COVID-19?
- How White Privilege Helped Me Succeed In BigLaw
- In Case You Missed It: Hottest Firms And Stories On Law360
- Dickinson Wright Snags IP Team From Brinks Gilson
- Judges Wary Of Remote Hearings' Impact On Legal Industry
- Skadden, Dechert To Give Workers Time Off On Juneteenth
- Law360's Pro Say: 'This Has To Stop'
- As BigLaw Explores New Pay Systems, Some Carry More Risk
- Fried Frank Offers To Buy Out Nonlawyers Amid Pandemic
- WeWork Wins Bid To Arbitrate Atty's Race, Gender Bias Suit
- Attys Accused In Molotov Attack Face Up To Life On 7 Counts
- Tyson & Mendes Reaches Gender Parity In Equity Partners
- Boston Attys Not Racing Back To Office As Virus Fears Linger
- Long Island Federal Judge Arthur D. Spatt Dies At 94
- New Trade Bar Chief Aims For Unity In Trump Era
- GC Cheat Sheet: The Hottest Corporate News Of The Week
- Judges Say Trial Court Not Rubber Stamp On Flynn Dismissal
- Work From Home Boom Reignites Atty Licensing Questions
- Pandemic Isn't Stopping Most Firms' Summer Programs
- If Nonlawyer Ownership Is The Future, It's A Jumble For Now
- Eversheds Sutherland Expands Legal Tech Service To US
- Pierce Bainbridge Breakup Sparks Rift In Boeing Class Suit
- GCs Report Burnout, Longer Hours During Pandemic
- Mass. Attys Step Up In 'Watershed Moment' For Racial Justice
- Gibson Dunn Reps Protesters In Trump Photo-Op Clash
- Calif. High Court Mulls Pushing Summer Bar Exam To Oct.
- Black DOJ Attys Demand 'Swift Action' On Police Reform
- Boies Schiller Loses Trial Pros Dunn, Isaacson To Paul Weiss
- How Firms Can Use Profitability Metrics To Their Advantage
- The Term: So Many Blockbusters, So Little Time
- High Court Attys Call On Barr To Resign After Protester Clash
- Divisive Bradley Arant Alum Advances Toward 5th Circ. Seat
- 9th Circ. Asks NY Justices If Litigation Funding Deal Is A Loan
- Keys To A Thriving Biz Development Culture At Your Law Firm
- Philip Morris Taps Manatt Atty As General Counsel
- Law360's Weekly Verdict: Legal Lions & Lambs
- Texas Atty Swaps Suits For Scrubs To Fight COVID-19
- As NYC's Courthouses Reopen, Virtual Court Will Remain
- Former Kirkland Partner Exiting Top DOJ Criminal Post
- Ex-DOJ Officials Want Review Of Barr's Role In Protest Clash
- Judiciary Says Fewer Jurors Is But One Fear As Trials Restart
- Firm Partners Can Boost Client Profitability With Small Tweaks
- Sidley Austin Signs On To Rep Journalist Blinded At Protest
- Loretta Lynch To Advise Probe Of NYPD Protest Conduct
- How 3 Firms Are Confronting The Obstacles Of Reopening
- Man Who Filed $400M Lien Against Judge Gets More Time
- UnitedLex Nabs 20 From Paul Hastings As Part Of Data JV
- Retired Judge Calls DOJ's Flynn Flip 'Gross Abuse Of Power'
- How Video Mediation Can Help Us Serve Clients Better
- Rakoff Blocks ICE From Arresting Immigrants At Courthouses
- Libra Scoops Credit Suisse, Goldman Vet As Compliance Chief
- Women Say New Info Supports Jones Day Pay Bias Collective
- USC Taps Former Jones Day, DOJ Atty As General Counsel
- Perkins Coie Joins Suit Over Seattle Police Use Of Force
- Law Firm Leaders: Stinson's Mark Hinderks
- Calif. Judicial Council Mulls Rollback Of Pandemic Rules
- Mental Health Efforts Will Support Diversity In Legal Industry
- Baker Botts Atty Takes Helm Of USPTO Silicon Valley Office
- NJ Ethics Head Aims To Sink Firm's Suit Over Name Rule
- How Firms Can Help Partners Increase Their Pricing Savvy
- Paul Weiss Partner To Lead Review Of Racism In NY Courts
- Judges To Return To NYC's State Courthouses As Virus Ebbs
- Millennial Partners Help Speed Change In Virus' Wake
- Debevoise Looks To Future Of Data Strategy With New Portal
- ABA Focuses On 'Significant Harm' In Prospective Client Rule
- More Firms Commit Funds To Aid Racial Justice
- Coronavirus Regulations: A State-By-State Week In Review
- Texas Judge Wants More Briefs In Pierce Bainbridge Debt Suit
- Former Sen. Trent Lott Ousted From Squire Patton Boggs
- Linklaters, JP Morgan And More Invest $27M In Legal Tech Co.
- House Dems Push Judiciary To Curb Ideological Memberships
- Goldberg Segalla Founder To Step Down After Nearly 20 Years
- Jones Day Fails To Get Sex Bias Accusers Punished
- Ex-Partner Wants Sanctions In Pierce Bainbridge Fraud Fight
- DC Moves Bar Exam Online, Set For October
- Firms Urge UK Gov't To Keep COVID-19 Recovery Sustainable
- Fired MSU Recruiter Sues Jones Day Over Sex Assault Inquiry
- Pa. Justices Add Anti-Bias Rule To Atty Ethics Code
- Wash. Justices Nix 'Innovative' Legal Access Program
- Law Firm Merger Boom May Be Coming Post-Lockdown
- Baker Botts Gets Suit Claiming Extortion Moved To Calif.
- Reed Smith Implements Hiring Freeze For Professional Staff
- Calif. Judge Up For Federal Bench In Eastern District
- 15 Minutes With Zillow Group's General Counsel
- Civility Could Be Litigators' New Normal Even Post-Pandemic
- Titan Of The Plaintiffs Bar: Stueve Siegel's Norman E. Siegel
- In Case You Missed It: Hottest Firms And Stories On Law360
- Attys In Floyd Case: An Inside Look At Civil Rights Work
- High Court Urged To Review Applying ADA To Bar Admissions
- Law360's Pro Say: Why Are Cops (Sort Of) Above The Law?
- Ex-Judge Suspended For 'Preposterous' Suit Over Lost Pants
- 2nd Circ. Orders Attys Charged In Molotov Attack Back To Jail
- ABA Wants Firms Working With Cannabis To Get Virus Aid
- Kennedys Goes West With New San Francisco Office
- Law Firms Must Beware Risks In Nontraditional Financing
- Wash. High Court Speaks Out Against Systemic Racism
- Zoom's CLO Promoted To Company's 1st COO
- Mich. Fed. Judge Stepping Down To Battle 'Treatable Cancer'
- Ex-Davis Polk Associate Says Bias Claims Are Timely
- Fed. Circ. Shut Down Friday Amid White House Protests
- Headhunter Lawsuits Shed Light On Fierce Lateral Market
- Titan Of The Plaintiffs Bar: Rosen Law Firm's Laurence Rosen
- GC Cheat Sheet: The Hottest Corporate News Of The Week
- Despite Virus, Legal Jobs Inched Up In May
- NYC Legal Observers Detained At George Floyd Protest
- NJ Judicial Pick Would Be State's 1st Black Female Justice
- Polsinelli, UnitedLex Launch IP Management Program
- Why LGBTQ Diversity At Firms Must Mean Leadership Roles
- Over 20 Fed. Courts Damaged During Police Brutality Protests
- Arnold & Porter, ACLU Steer Suit Over Photo Op Clash
- The Term: Sotomayor Scorches On Pensions, Puerto Rico
- Virus Has Workers' Lawyers Shifting From Litigation To Advice
- How In-House Attys Can Build Resilience Despite Disruptions
- Ex-Pfizer Global Trade Counsel Joins StoneTurn As NY Partner
- Law Group Says Floyd Remarks Met With Threats, Twitter Halt
- Fed. Circ. Judge Skeptical Of Atty's PACER Fee Fight
- Validity Finance Hires Arbitral Atty To Head New Israel Office
- Cooley's $450K Gift Latest From BigLaw To Aid Racial Justice
- Titan Of The Plaintiffs Bar: Robins Kaplan's K. Craig Wildfang
- GOP Advances Ex-Kavanaugh Clerk Toward DC Circ. Seat
- 2 Tested Alternatives To Unavoidable Court Delays
- Minn. Ruling Represents Sensible Stance On Legal Finance
- Can The Legal Industry Adapt In COVID-19's Wake?
- GCs Forced To Juggle As Legal Teams Face COVID-19 Cuts
- In-Person Deposition Bid Nixed In King & Spalding Firing Suit
- Law360's Weekly Verdict: Legal Lions & Lambs
- Freshfields Partly Escapes Recruiter's Claims Over Cleary Hire
- As Protests Rage, Supreme Court Eyes Immunity For Cops
- Judges Worried About Virus' Impact On Upcoming Trials
- Manatt Failed Promise To Sue Under Armour, Suit Says
- Armstrong Teasdale Opens Southern Illinois Office
- Geragos Law Firm Wants Travelers' COVID-19 Suit Tossed
- Mass. Justices Call For Introspection Amid Racial Tumult
- Orrick Plans Racial Justice Fellowship After Floyd Killing
- DOJ Files High Court Appeal Over Mueller Grand Jury Docs
- Law Firm Leaders: Katten's Noah Heller
- Divided Senate Confirms BakerHostetler Atty For Texas Court
- Best Practices For A Paperless Law Practice
- Titan of the Plaintiffs Bar: Oppenheim's Matt Oppenheim
- Dorsey Ends Effort With City Prosecutors After Floyd Killing
- 3 Qualities That Help Law Firms Thrive In Times Of Crisis
- LA Courts To Launch New Remote Appearance System
- How Public And Private Cos. Use Their GCs Differently
- NY Judge Who Called Atty C-Word Says It Was 'Compliment'
- Calif. Judge Johnson Removed Over Sexual Misconduct
- These Firms Are Handling The Most Product Liability Cases
- Skadden, Clio Open Checkbooks Amid George Floyd Protests
- Coronavirus Regulations: A State-By-State Week In Review
- Lawyers Must Address Racial Injustice With Radical Candor
- Pryor Cashman Suspends Atty Charged In Molotov Attack
- Counsel Who Care: How Attys Are Helping During A Crisis
- Titan Of The Plaintiffs Bar: Miner Barnhill's Robert Libman
- Firm Says Atty Behind Sex Bias Suit Drove Client Away
- McGuireWoods Hit With Retaliation Suit By Ex-Paralegal
- Law Firm Sued For Age Bias Over Employee 'Scorecards'
- Judge Defends Refusal To 'Rubber Stamp' DOJ's Flynn Move
- Before Virus Hit, Drop In Law Grads Led To Better Job Market
- Bail For Pryor Cashman Atty Charged In NYC Molotov Attack
- Schiff Hardin Didn't Breach Contract With Former Partner
- Texas Bar Escapes 1st Amendment Suit Over Mandatory Dues
- Jailed Protesters Find Attorneys Ready To Take Up Their Case
- Ex-Public Defender Confirmed To Federal Bench In Florida
- Pierce Bainbridge Funder Says Firm Defaulted On Debt
- Law Firms Speak Out Amid Turmoil Over Police Brutality
- How Lawyers Can Network Better, Virtually And In Person
- Practical Tips For Presenting Your Case To Litigation Funders
- 'Strange' Times For Mass. Judges As Virus Redefines Court
- Reed Smith Makes Deeper Austerity Cut As Virus Persists
- Bayer Slams Pet Med Co.'s Bid To Serve Docs Via Email
- Titan Of The Plaintiffs Bar: Lieff Cabraser's Jonathan Selbin
- 2 Partners Say NY Firm Stiffed Them On Compensation
- 15 Minutes With Xandr's Chief Legal Officer
- Boies Adds 2 From DOJ As Another Partner Exits In NY
- High Court Turns Away Wis. Bar Dues Case Despite Dissent