General Liability

  • December 19, 2023

    SC Jury Finds Insurers Correctly Denied Fire Loss Coverage

    A South Carolina state jury unanimously said three insurers correctly denied coverage to a property management company for damage and losses stemming from a 2019 fire, finding a policy endorsement required automatic sprinkler systems to be connected, maintained and in working order, according to a verdict sheet filed Tuesday.

  • December 18, 2023

    Restoration Co. Not Covered For Homeowner's Lost Property

    An insurer doesn't owe coverage to a restoration company for a $428,000 judgment reached over a woman's lost and damaged property, a Virginia federal court ruled Monday, finding that the company failed to notify its insurer of the initial loss and subsequent lawsuit.

  • December 18, 2023

    Insurer Wants Out Of Covering Defense In BIPA Class Action

    A Pennsylvania insurer filed a declaratory judgment action against an Illinois supply chain management firm in Illinois state court, asking the court to determine that it owes no duty to defend or indemnify the firm in an underlying putative class action regarding an alleged biometric privacy violation.

  • December 18, 2023

    SC Judge Won't Reconsider Foam Co. Dismissal Ruling

    A South Carolina federal judge refused to reconsider or certify for interlocutory appeal a ruling denying a group of insurers' bid to dismiss a firefighting foam company's coverage dispute, finding Monday that there are insufficient grounds to dismiss the case and that approving it for appeal would promote "piecemeal litigation."

  • December 18, 2023

    3rd Circ. Tosses Insurer Win In Nursing Home Coverage Row

    A Third Circuit panel vacated an insurer's quick win against a nursing home company facing claims from long-term care residents who contracted COVID-19, saying the coverage fight wasn't yet ripe for the district court because the company hadn't met its policy's $3 million self-insured retention threshold.

  • December 18, 2023

    $8B Counterclaims In Chinese Insurer's Hotel Theft Suit Fail

    A California federal judge tossed $8 billion in counterclaims made by a law firm and an investor accused by a Chinese insurer of playing a role in a billion-dollar title theft scheme involving American luxury hotels in New York and California.

  • December 15, 2023

    NY Archdiocese Escapes Chubb Suit Over Sex Abuse Claims

    A New York judge on Friday tossed a lawsuit brought by Chubb Insurance against the Archdiocese of New York over a slew of sex abuse complaints the church is facing, saying that under the "plain language" of the policies the church held, it is "obvious" they cover the lawsuits. 

  • December 15, 2023

    Generator Co. Wasn't Liable For Fire, Judge Says

    A portable generator company doesn't have to reimburse an insurer for damages it covered after a fire broke out at a policyholder's home, a Minnesota federal court said, finding that the insurer failed to present evidence that would allow it to prevail on design or manufacturing defect claims.

  • December 15, 2023

    Insurer Escapes Covering Ky. Contractors In Defects Row

    A federal judge allowed an insurer to escape coverage for a pair of contractors embroiled in a defective construction dispute with the owner of a Louisville, Kentucky, apartment complex, finding Friday that the underlying claims were not covered under its policy.

  • December 15, 2023

    3rd Circ. Won't Give Early Boot To Boy Scouts' Ch. 11 Appeals

    A panel of the Third Circuit won't toss appeals challenging the Boy Scouts of America's Chapter 11 plan as moot, it said in an order, adding that it plans to consider the merits of the cases.

  • December 15, 2023

    Mich. Panel Begrudgingly Reverses Progressive's Early Win

    An orthopedic clinic has standing to sue Progressive in a no-fault insurance dispute due to prior rulings, a Michigan state appeals court has said, despite finding that the clinic transferred its right to pursue payment to multiple third-party companies.

  • December 15, 2023

    5th Circ. Backs Insurer's Defeat Of 401(k) Exit Fee Suit

    The Fifth Circuit refused to reinstate a dental office's proposed class action alleging an insurer unlawfully charged fees to 401(k) plans that left its platform, saying the insurer had no duty under federal benefits law to waive the charges.

  • December 14, 2023

    Contractor Gets Order Tweaked In Quantico Construction Suit

    A Virginia federal judge granted a contractor’s request to modify an insurer’s proposed order for default judgment against a third-party construction company in a dispute over defective work at a U.S. Navy school, adding language to the order to prevent it from affecting the contractor’s other ongoing suits.

  • December 14, 2023

    AIG Says Fla. Marina Must Pay For Damaged Boat

    AIG is seeking reimbursement of over $240,000 from a Miami marina, telling a Florida federal court that the marina's negligence contributed to a boat lift malfunction, which left its policyholder's boat damaged beyond repair.

  • December 14, 2023

    Geico Prioritized Noninsured In Auto Suit, 9th Circ. Told

    Geico unreasonably refused to settle a wrongful death suit against its policyholder by prioritizing a noninsured party over its actual insured, according to a brief filed in the Ninth Circuit by the parents of a person who died after the policyholder struck him with a vehicle.

  • December 14, 2023

    Home Depot Brings $50M Data Breach Loss To 6th Circ.

    Home Depot urged the Sixth Circuit to reverse a lower court's ruling that its insurers don't owe over $50 million in coverage for defense and settlement costs for a 2014 data breach, maintaining that the court incorrectly applied the policies' electronic data exclusion to bar coverage.

  • December 13, 2023

    Auto Shop Holding Hail-Damaged Cars Hostage, Insurer Says

    An auto repair shop is unfairly refusing to release to its insurer cars that the insurer took ownership of as part of a settlement with a dealership on behalf of the shop, the insurer told an Arkansas federal court, saying the shop is taking advantage of the situation.

  • December 13, 2023

    Insurer Warns Of 2024 Geopolitical Challenges For Companies

    Company bosses face the threat of legal action next year over failures on geopolitical factors, artificial intelligence and concerns about the environment, an insurer warned Wednesday.

  • December 13, 2023

    Lessor Denies Delaying $97M Payout Over Lost Plane

    An aircraft lessor told a London court that it has already paid out an indemnity following the destruction of its leased plane in Sudan and that therefore a claim by a Saudi airline for $97 million in insurance proceeds should fall away.

  • December 13, 2023

    UK Motor Insurers Face 'Worst Losses In Decade' In 2023

    Motor insurance companies in the U.K. are likely to face punishing losses this year, Ernst & Young said Wednesday, as the firm warned that hikes in premiums have failed to keep pace with the spiraling cost of claims.

  • December 12, 2023

    Costco Not Covered For Icy Parking Lot Injury Suit

    A New York federal judge dismissed Costco's counterclaims against Travelers in a coverage dispute over an underlying personal injury lawsuit against the wholesale retailer and a snow removal company, finding Costco didn't meet the policy's standards to receive coverage as an indemnitee of the insured.

  • December 12, 2023

    Liberty Mutual Loses Dismissal Bid In Spyware Suit

    Liberty Mutual can't escape a proposed class action accusing it of using software to track customers' actions on its website without consent, a Pennsylvania federal court ruled, finding the lawsuit adequately alleged that software can be considered a "device" under wiretapping laws.

  • December 12, 2023

    Insurer Says Oil Co. Not Covered For Contamination Suits

    An insurer urged a Louisiana federal court to find that it doesn't owe coverage to an oil company accused in multiple state court lawsuits of negligently operating wells, tanks and flowlines that resulted in property contamination, arguing that the alleged damages are precluded under the policy.

  • December 12, 2023

    2nd Circ. Upholds Zurich's Win In Subrogation Dispute

    The Second Circuit on Tuesday affirmed Zurich's win in a suit seeking to prevent certain Lloyd's of London underwriters from subrogating against their mutual insured.

  • December 12, 2023

    No Coverage For Fatal Party Shooting, Calif. Panel Says

    A Farmers unit had no duty to defend or indemnify a man who fatally shot a guest at a house party and pled guilty to manslaughter, a California state appeals court affirmed, finding that the policy's intentional acts exclusion applied to a subsequent wrongful death suit.

Expert Analysis

  • Reinsurers Must Prepare For Coronavirus-Related Claims

    Author Photo

    Given the tremendous volume of insurance claims expected as a result of COVID-19 and the possibility that these claims will lead to reinsurance cessions, reinsurers should promptly review their assumed portfolios to determine their potential exposure, say Scott Seaman and Edward Lenci at Hinshaw & Culbertson.

  • Does COVID-19 Fall Under Insurers' Pollution Exclusions?

    Author Photo

    Despite inconsistent rulings from state and federal courts, an analysis of bacterial and viral contamination cases provides insight on whether COVID-19 is the type of environmental harm expected to fall within insurance policies' pollution provisions, says Elise Allen at BatesCarey.

  • Should States Force Property Insurers To Cover Virus Losses?

    Author Photo

    A proposed New Jersey bill requiring some commercial property insurance policies to construe the coronavirus pandemic as a covered cause of loss would likely survive a contract clause challenge, but this type of law could set a dangerous precedent, say Linda Hsu and Savannah Montanez at Selman Breitman.

  • Don't Assume 'Physical Loss' Language Bars Virus Coverage

    Author Photo

    A recent Law360 guest article mistakenly assumes that many standard insurance policies will not cover COVID-19 business interruptions without a specialized endorsement, when in actuality courts will not automatically deny such claims because of a physical damage requirement, says Stacy Tucker at Kantor & Kantor.

  • 8 Possible Paths To Insurance Coverage For COVID-19 Losses

    Author Photo

    At least some insurance policies are almost certain to apply to coronavirus-related losses, and a few hypothetical situations explain how, say attorneys at Covington.

  • Future Battles Foreshadowed In First COVID-19 Insurance Suit

    Author Photo

    The first insurance lawsuit on record for coronavirus coverage — Oceana Grill v. Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's, filed in Louisiana state court — highlights key questions that will be echoed across the country and underscores the importance of acting now to preserve claims, says Tae Andrews at Miller Friel.

  • NJ Cos. May Have Insurance Coverage For COVID-19 Losses

    Author Photo

    Two New Jersey cases from 2009 and 2014 indicate that the physical injury requirement under property insurance policies may be interpreted broadly enough to apply to losses resulting from the coronavirus crisis, say Robert Chesler and Nicholas Insua at Anderson Kill.

  • Risk Mitigation Tools For Cos. Facing Coronavirus Losses

    Author Photo

    As the coronavirus outbreak continues to spread, companies anticipating business interruptions can look to insurance policies and alternatives like force majeure clauses to offset potential losses, say attorneys at Haynes and Boone.

  • NY Sex Abuse Insurance Suit Showcases Possible Arguments

    Author Photo

    Continental Insurance's complaint against the Diocese of Buffalo in a New York state court raises almost every possible defense an insurer may have against providing coverage to a policyholder accused of sex abuse under the New York Child Victims Act, say Robert Chesler and Pamela Hans of Anderson Kill.

  • How Courts And Litigants Can Benefit From Special Masters

    Author Photo

    As we approach the first anniversary of the American Bar Association's adoption of guidelines for the appointment and use of special masters in civil litigation, retired U.S. District Judge Shira Scheindlin, now at Stroock, explains how special masters can help parties and courts with faster decision-making and subject matter expertise.

  • Using Missing Facts As A Defense In NYC Asbestos Suits

    Author Photo

    Recent cases from the New York City Asbestos Litigation illustrate that defendants can prevail by arguing that the evidentiary record cannot support an inference of a plaintiff's exposure to asbestos, says James Lee of Hawkins Parnell.

  • Ill. Insurance Coverage Cases From 2019 Settle Key Questions

    Author Photo

    A number of significant insurance decisions in Illinois this year — including a state Supreme Court case that reestablished certainty for malicious prosecution coverage — should have a lasting effect on Illinois coverage jurisprudence, say Jonathan Schwartz and Timothy Loftus of Goldberg Segalla.

  • Private Equity Wants To Buy Your Asbestos Liabilities

    Author Photo

    BorgWarner's deal to sell off its asbestos liabilities this week confirms that such sales are a viable corporate strategy that can be less expensive than, and offer disclosure advantages over, prepackaged bankruptcy and loss portfolio insurance. But they still come with a cost, and can raise trust and security issues, says Stephen Hoke of Hoke LLC.