Hernandez v. The Office of the Commissioner of Baseball et al

  1. July 25, 2019

    No 'Union Privilege' For Umpire's Docs In MLB Race Bias Case

    A New York federal judge on Thursday shot down the latest attempt by a Major League Baseball umpire to keep his communications with the umpires' union out of his race bias suit against the league, ruling that a magistrate judge who ordered him to turn over the documents made no errors.

  2. July 11, 2019

    MLB Umpire's Punitive Damage Claim Strikes Out In Bias Suit

    A New York federal judge on Thursday threw out a Major League Baseball umpire's claims for punitive damage under Ohio state law in his race bias suit against the league, ruling that he can't make claims based on the same conduct under two conflicting state laws.

  3. July 03, 2019

    MLB Cries Foul On Umpire's 'Union Privilege' Objection

    Major League Baseball has urged a New York federal court to force an umpire suing the league over alleged race bias to turn over his correspondence with the umpires' union, saying federal law doesn't recognize the so-called "union relations privilege" outside of a disciplinary hearing.

  4. June 27, 2019

    MLB Umpire Balks At Giving Up Union Docs In Race Bias Suit

    An umpire suing Major League Baseball for race bias has objected to a New York magistrate judge's decision ordering him to cough up communications between him and the MLB umpires union, saying doing so would undermine the confidentiality that the union and its members need.

  5. June 13, 2019

    Umpire Must Turn Over Union Docs To MLB In Race Bias Suit

    A New York magistrate judge has ordered an umpire suing Major League Baseball for racial bias to hand over to the league any communications between him and the umpires union related to game assignments, grievances, discipline and other issues. 

  6. June 10, 2019

    MLB, Umpire Clash Over Union Subpoena In Race Bias Suit

    Major League Baseball and an umpire accusing the league of racial bias have initiated a dispute over whether a subpoena issued to the umpire's union for internal communications runs afoul of a "union relations privilege."

  7. April 03, 2019

    MLB Says Umpire Can't Discuss Racial Bias Suit With Media

    Major League Baseball is asking a New York federal court to deny an umpire's motion for clearance to speak with the media about his racial discrimination claims against the league, saying the court can't judge if his statements cross a legal line until he says them.