Circuit Check Inc. v. QXQ Inc.

  1. August 03, 2015

    Fed. Circ.'s Rebuke Of Judge Shows Limits Of Obviousness

    The Federal Circuit's recent decision that a judge wrongly overruled a jury and declared patents obvious based on simple concepts unrelated to the invention shows that there are limits on the prior art that can be used to render a patent obvious, creating a hurdle for accused infringers, attorneys say.

  2. July 28, 2015

    Prior Art Must Relate To Patent For Obviousness: Fed. Circ.

    The Federal Circuit found Tuesday that a Wisconsin federal judge wrongly overturned a $1.86 million patent jury verdict won by Circuit Check Inc. against rival QXQ Inc., ruling that the prior art he said rendered the patents obvious involved simple concepts unrelated to the invention.