April 24, 2019
A California federal judge scrapped a patent suit against SAP America and HP on Wednesday, finding that the allegedly infringing product actually preexisted software maker Big Baboon's patented e-commerce designs.
August 28, 2018
A California federal judge on Tuesday refused to toss a software company's suit claiming SAP America Inc. and HP Inc. infringed its patented e-commerce designs, finding the allegations pass the pleading bar under the high court's Twombly ruling.
August 16, 2018
A California federal judge appeared unswayed Thursday by SAP America Inc. and HP Inc.’s arguments that a software company hasn't met the stringent pleading standards required under the U.S. Supreme Court’s Twombly decision, saying Twombly has created more work than it’s saved, and "you get to the point where we’re wasting time and resources when you know what their pleading is."
June 26, 2017
SAP America and HP urged a California federal judge on Friday to sanction a Silicon Valley software company and its attorneys for filing a new infringement suit in sprawling litigation over an e-commerce patent, saying "one attempted fishing expedition is enough."