The debate regarding whether incarcerated people who perform work are employees and thus entitled to federal wage and hour protections is continuing to develop.
The U.S. Supreme Court in April declined to review a Fourth Circuit panel decision that paved the way for a potential finding that incarcerated workers in some circumstances can be employees under the Fair Labor Standards Act, but other petitions remain pending.
The justices are still considering a certiorari petition by the GEO Group, which is seeking to undo a Tenth Circuit panel decision that the private prison operator was too quick to appeal a ruling that it lacked sovereign immunity from immigrant detainees' claims.
And in the Ninth Circuit, the GEO Group has filed a rehearing petition in consolidated cases after a split panel affirmed a $23 million win in another case involving immigrant detainees.
While federal courts had previously found that workers behind bars were not employees, "courts are increasingly skeptical," said D. Michael Hancock of Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll PLLC, who has represented such workers. "At some point, this issue's going to have to make its way to the Supreme Court and get decided once and for all."
To hear more from Hancock, and the defense argument, listen to Law360 Explores: Subminimum Wage Part 2.
--Additional reporting by Daniela Porat and Britain Eakin.
Workers Behind Bars is a special series from Law360 exploring the push to end subminimum wages and forced labor for detained and incarcerated workers and the labor laws central to this dispute. Have a story idea for Access to Justice? Reach us at accesstojustice@law360.com.
Try our Advanced Search for more refined results
Law360
|The Practice of Law
Access to Justice
Aerospace & Defense
Appellate
Asset Management
Banking
Bankruptcy
Benefits
California
Cannabis
Capital Markets
Class Action
Colorado
Commercial Contracts
Competition
Compliance
Connecticut
Construction
Consumer Protection
Corporate
Cybersecurity & Privacy
Delaware
Employment
Energy
Environmental
Fintech
Florida
Food & Beverage
Georgia
Government Contracts
Health
Hospitality
Illinois
Immigration
Insurance
Intellectual Property
International Arbitration
International Trade
Legal Ethics
Legal Industry
Life Sciences
Massachusetts
Media & Entertainment
Mergers & Acquisitions
Michigan
Native American
Law360 Pulse
|Business of Law
Law360 Authority
|Deep News & Analysis
Healthcare Authority
Deals & Corporate Governance Digital Health & Technology Other Policy & ComplianceGlobal
- Law360
- Law360 UK
- Law360 Pulse
- Law360 Employment Authority
- Law360 Tax Authority
- Law360 Insurance Authority
- Law360 Real Estate Authority
- Law360 Healthcare Authority
- Law360 Bankruptcy Authority
- Products
- Lexis®
- Law360 In-Depth
- Law360 Podcasts
- Rankings
- Leaderboard Analytics
- Regional Powerhouses
- Law360's MVPs
- Women in Law Report
- Law360 400
- Diversity Snapshot
- Practice Groups of the Year
- Rising Stars
- Titans of the Plaintiffs Bar
- Sections
- Adv. Search & Platform Tools
- About all sections
- Browse all sections
- Banking
- Bankruptcy
- Class Action
- Competition
- Employment
- Energy
- Expert Analysis
- Insurance
- Intellectual Property
- Product Liability
- Securities
- Beta Tools
- Track docs
- Track attorneys
- Track judges
This article has been saved to your Briefcase
This article has been added to your Saved Articles
Listen: Prison Wages Debate Evolving With Petitions Pending
By Max Kutner | May 8, 2025, 7:22 PM EDT · Listen to article