9th Circ. Grants Smuggling Retrial Over Destroyed Evidence

Law360, New York (May 7, 2013, 7:36 PM EDT) -- Criminal defendants who are prejudiced by the government's destruction of evidence are entitled to a remedial jury instruction but not necessarily an outright dismissal of their case, the Ninth Circuit ruled Tuesday, ordering a retrial for a convicted Mexican man accused of drug smuggling.

A three-judge panel said that the U.S. acted negligently in auctioning defendant Victor Hugo Sivilla's Jeep vehicle, which was a main piece of evidence in his drug smuggling trial. While the government did not act in bad faith in destroying the evidence,...
To view the full article, register now.
Law360 Pro Say Podcast
Check out Law360's new podcast, Pro Say, which offers a weekly recap of both the biggest stories and hidden gems from the world of law.